Turn Fear Into Thrill: How to Make Taboos Playful Instead of Scary

We’re not here to convince you that taboos are fun, they often feel scary for a good reason. Instead, for the final article themed around Honest X and Halloween spooks, we’ve created a guided approach to let curiosity lead the way, so you can test the edges gently, discover what truly excites you, and transform what was once off-limits into something playful, intimate, and alive.

This is your step-by-step guide. Try it at your own pace.

1. Map Your “Scary Zone”

Start by naming what feels taboo or scary for you. It’s ok if it’s vague.

• Grab paper or your notes app.
• Draw three concentric rings (like a target).
  • In the innermost ring, write things you already experiment with or talk about (comfort zone).
  • In the middle ring, list things you’re curious about but feel nervous to try (edge zone).
  • In the outer ring, place things you almost never talk about, your big taboos, the “too scary” stuff.

Having this visual helps you see that “taboo” isn’t a wall, it’s layered territory. Like an onion!

Exercise: Then pick one item in your middle ring. That’s your play target, something just beyond comfort but not maximal risk.

2. “Curiosity Interview” for You or Your Partner

Once you’ve chosen your play target, interview yourself, or your partner, about it.

Use these prompts:

• What is the fear behind this? (Rejection? Shame? Embarrassment?)
• What would it feel like to shift this fear to curiosity?
• If you could ask this taboo one question, what would you want to know?
• What’s the smallest way to try it, without full commitment?

If you’re with a partner, take turns interviewing each other, listen first, respond second. The point is not agreement. It’s discovering why something feels big and intimidating.

3. Design a Micro-Experiment

You don’t have to jump all the way, you can test a mini version.

• Choose a low-stakes version of your taboo.
• Give it a time limit (5 minutes, one conversation, one message, etc.).
• Use a boundary check-in before and after (“On a scale 1-10, how safe/curious do I feel right now?”).

Examples:

• If your taboo is “telling a fantasy,” try just writing it down alone and reading it back to yourself.
• If it’s “asking for more in bed,” try asking for one small adjustment (e.g. “a little firmer there”) instead of making a grand request.
• If it’s “role play,” begin with a silly, low-risk scenario (e.g. teacher-student in socks) rather than your deep fantasy.

Track how you feel before, during, and after.

4. Use Prompt Cards as Jump-Starters

When words fail, tools can help. You can use our Honest X collection to seed conversation around your target taboo.

• Pull a card at random.
• If it speaks to your target taboo, use it as your conversation opener (e.g. “What fuels your desires?”).
• If it’s too off-topic, discard and draw again. There’s freedom in choosing what you respond to.

Prompts shift the burden of phrasing and coming up with your own exploration questions, letting curiosity lead instead of performance.

Sign up for The Skin Deep

We're the Skin Deep. An Emmy award-winning experience design studio exploring human emotion, intimacy and connection in relationships, through meaningful content, innovative card games and other experiences.

Subscribe

Email sent! Check your inbox to complete your signup.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

5. Normalize The Pause & Rewind

When exploring something new, you’ll hit “stop points”, discomfort, surprise, confusion. That’s healthy.

• If you feel overwhelmed, pause. Say: “I need a minute.”
• Rewind: check in, “What part feels like too much?”
• Adjust the pace or scale back the experiment.
• Celebrate the fact you took the step, not how far you went.

Thrill is about expansion, not “winning.” Honor your pace.

6. Journal the Results & Insights

After each experiment (even the tiniest one), write down:

• What surprised you?
• What felt better than expected?
• What parts still feel too scary and why?
• What could you try next, slightly more daring, if you felt safe?

This turns your attempts into data. Over time, you’ll see a pattern of growth, and you’ll have your own toolbox of what works for you (or you + partner).

7. Ritualize a Permission Statement

Create a short “permission statement” you can say before stepping into a taboo:

“I allow curiosity, I allow weirdness, I allow surprise.” or “It’s ok not to know, it’s ok to change my mind.”

Say it quietly to yourself, or together with your partner, before each experiment. It shifts your nervous system: you’re giving yourself explicit permission to play.

Bringing It Into Real Use

• Do a weekly micro-experiment, even 5 minutes.
• Keep your “scary zone map” visible and update it when something moves inward.
• Use prompt cards when conversation feels stuck.
• At the end of month one, look back on your journal: you’ll see new territory you didn’t think you could visit.

Turning Fear Into Fuel

Fear isn’t the enemy of desire, it’s the doorway. Every time you approach what scares you with curiosity, you build a bridge between safety and excitement. That bridge is where intimacy lives.

So don’t aim to be fearless. Aim to be playful in the face of fear. That’s where thrill begins.

Close the Loop: The Halloween Series Finale 🎃

This article marks the end of our Honest X Halloween series, a month of exploring the beautifully haunted corners of intimacy.

If you’ve made it this far, take a breath. You’ve faced curiosity, fear, honesty, and now, play.

But don’t stop here. Revisit the earlier chapters of your journey:

• The Real Monsters in the Bedroom: Why Talking About Sex Feels So Scary - We grew up fearing monsters under the bed. But what if the real monsters live between us, in the things we don’t say? This article peels back how shame, fear, and silence haunt our conversations about sex.
• Unmasking Desire: How to Reveal What You Really Want - We all wear masks, the confident one, the safe one, the person-pleaser. In this article, we practice taking them off, naming what we truly want, and giving ourselves permission to evolve.
• Ghosted in Bed: The Taboos We Pretend Don’t Exist - Ever vanished in the middle of intimacy? In this piece, we call out the silences, the disappearances, and the unspoken rules we all pretend don’t exist, and turn them into openings for connection.

Together, they form a map, from shadow to light, from fear to thrill.
Here’s to curiosity, courage, and the kind of honesty that turns the dark into play.

Happy Halloween. 💋

Regina Zuniga
The Skin Deep Digital Content Specialist